Discredited Bishops, Archbishops and Cardinals
Since 1990, at least 27 bishops, archbishops and cardinals
around the world have resigned or been stood down after allegations of sexual
misconduct, on their own part or of those they supervised, became public;
however, this may not be a complete list. Where not otherwise specified,
details were sourced from the Boston Globe website 11th June 2004. Note:
In the Mormon Church, the bishop is the local parish clergyperson. This
list only refers to senior church leaders, not parish clergy.
ARGENTINA
Catholic Archbishop Edgardo Storni of Santa Fe resigned on Oct. 1, 2002, after a
book accused him of abusing at least 47 young seminarians. The Vatican had
investigated allegations against Storni in 1994, but found insufficient evidence
to act. Storni said his resignation did not
signify guilt.
AUSTRALIA
2002 Governor-General Peter Hollingworth, former Anglican Archbishop of
Brisbane, resigned in May as Governor-General in the wake of an inquiry and
report into sex abuse in the diocese during his 11 year tenure (1990-2001)
via news and media releases
2004 Ian George, Anglican Archbishop of Adelaide, resigned 11th June in the wake
of a report into abuse within the diocese of Adelaide. via
news and media releases
2004 Retired Anglican Bishop Donald Shearman was defrocked in August for sexual misconduct with a 14yo girl in the 1950s. It is believed Shearman is the first bishop worldwide to be defrocked for sex offences. via news and media releases
AUSTRIA
Cardinal Hans Hermann Groer of Vienna was forced by the Vatican to retire in
April 1995 following allegations he repeatedly abused students
at an all-male Catholic high school in Hollabrunn in the 1970s. Groer rejected
the accusations. He subsequently died in 2003.
Catholic Bishop Kurt Krenn, of St Polten, resigned in October
2004, three months after a pornography scandal at his diocesan
seminary. The Pope appointed an apostolic visitor, or special
investigator, on 20 July to look into events at the St Polten seminary, after
Vienna's Profil magazine published pictures of priests and students engaged in
intimate acts. The seminary's rector and vice-rector resigned in the wake of the
scandal, while a Polish seminarian received a six months' suspended sentence for
storing child pornography on a computer. Pope John Paul II personally
wrote to Krenn demanding his resignation, but Krenn still claims he was the
victim of a "great injustice". via Ecumenical News
International 1/10/04
CANADA
Bishop Hubert O'Connor of Prince George, British Columbia, was sentenced on
Sept. 13, 1996, to 2 1/2 years in prison for sexually assaulting two
teenage girls at a boarding school in central British Colombia while he was
principal there in the 1960s.
Archbishop Alphonsus Penney of St. John's, Newfoundland,
resigned on February 2, 1991, after a church commission criticized him for
failing
to prevent extensive abuse of boys living in Newfoundland orphanages.
GERMANY
Auxiliary Bishop Franziskus Eisenbach of Mainz resigned on April 16, 2002, after
a female university professor accused him of sexually
assaulting her during an exorcism. Eisenbach denied the allegation and the
Vatican said his resignation was not an admission of guilt.
IRELAND
Bishop Brendan Comiskey of Ferns is the first known member of the church
hierarchy to resign voluntarily over his management of an abusive
priest. Comiskey stepped down on April 1, 2002, after coming under fire for his
handling of the Rev. Sean Fortune, an accused pedophile.
Comiskey apologized for his conduct and the church launched a probe of the
scandal.
Bishop Eamonn Casey of Galway stepped down on May 7, 1992, after admitting he
had fathered the son of a Connecticut woman while having an
affair with her in 1973. Casey used church offerings to pay the woman thousands
of dollars in child support.
POLAND
Archbishop Juliusz Paetz of Poznan, a close associate of Pope John Paul II,
resigned on March 28, 2002, amid accusations he had made sexual
advances on young clerics. Paetz denied the allegations, but said he was
resigning "for the good of the church." The Vatican conducted an
inconclusive investigation of the case.
SCOTLAND
Bishop Roderick Wright of Argyll and the Isles resigned on Sept. 16, 1996, after
admitting an affair with a mother of three who he met while
counseling her during her divorce. After his resignation, Wright and the woman
married. Wright acknowledged that he had fathered a son by another
woman earlier in his career.
SWITZERLAND
Bishop Hansjoerg Vogel of Basel resigned on June 2, 1995, after admitting he had
impregnated a woman following his appointment to the
hierarchy the year before.
UNITED STATES
TUCSON, ARIZ.
Bishop Manuel D. Moreno resigned on March 7, 2003, citing health reasons (he
suffers from early Parkinson's disease and prostate cancer). Moreno
apologized for his handling of Monsignor Robert C. Trupia, a multiple abuser,
and other priests. The Tucson diocese settled 11 clergy abuse
lawsuits for an estimated $14 million in 2002.
PHOENIX, ARIZ.
Bishop Michael J Neils resigned as bishop of the ELCA (Evangelical Lutheran
Church of America) and as an ordained minister on 24th Jan 2006, after admitting
to sexual misconduct with an adult woman. via ELCA News
27/1/06
BOSTON
Cardinal Bernard Law, perhaps America's most powerful Catholic Church official,
resigned on Dec. 13, 2002, after a year of growing criticism
over his failure to remove abusive priests from ministry in the Boston
Archdiocese.
SRINGFIELD, MA
Thomas L. Dupre resigned abruptly in Feb 2004 after being accused of raping two
boys in the 1970s. A subsequent grand jury investigation decided in September
2004 to indict Dupre, but the DA decided not to prosecute because it was so far
outside the statute of limitations. At the time of the indictment, Springfield
diocese said they did not know where Dupre was, and that he was only answerable
to the Holy See and the pope. Charges in other jurisdictions and federally
were still pending at the time of indictment. via Boston
Globe
NEW YORK
Auxiliary Bishop James McCarthy, former secretary to the late Cardinal John
O'Connor, resigned on June 11, 2002, after admitting he had affairs
with several women, reportedly including a 21-year-old.
LEXINGTON, KY.
Bishop J. Kendrick Williams resigned on June 11, 2002, after being accused in
lawsuits against the Archdiocese of Louisville of abusing two
minors and an 18-year-old decades ago. Williams denied the accusations.
MILWAUKEE
Archbishop Rembert Weakland resigned on May 25, 2002, after it became known that
the Milwaukee Archdiocese in 1998 paid a $450,000 settlement to a man who
claimed Weakland tried to assault him in 1979. Weakland admitted to an
"inappropriate relationship" with the man but denied the abuse charge.
PALM BEACH, FLA.
*
Bishop Anthony O'Connell resigned on March 8, 2002, after admitting he
repeatedly abused a teenage boy at the Hannibal, Mo., seminary he led
during the 1970s. The victim received a $125,000 settlement from the Diocese of
Jefferson City in 1996. Fall River, Mass., Bishop Sean
Patrick O'Malley was named to replace him.
* Bishop J. Keith Symons, who preceded Bishop Anthony O'Connell as
head of the Palm Beach Diocese, became the first US bishop to resign over child
sexual abuse on June 1, 1998. Symons admitted to molesting five teenage boys at
three Florida parishes earlier in his career.
SANTA ROSA, CALIF.
Bishop G. Patrick Ziemann resigned on July 21, 1999, when a California priest
claimed Ziemann had coerced him into sex acts after learning the
priest had stolen parish funds. Ziemann confirmed the sexual relationship, but
claimed it was consensual.
SANTA FE, N.M.
Archbishop Robert Sanchez, the nation's first Hispanic bishop, resigned on March
19, 1993, after admitting he had sexual relationships with at
least five young women in New Mexico in the 1970s and '80s.
ATLANTA
The late Archbishop Eugene Marino, the nation's first black archbishop, resigned
on July 10, 1990, upon admitting having an "intimate"
relationship with a female parishioner in her 20s. Marino died in November 2000.
WALES
Archbishop John Aloysius Ward of Cardiff, Wales, was forced by the pope to
resign on Oct. 26, 2001, after he was accused of ignoring warnings
about two priests who were later convicted of child abuse.
Main page / frameless * Site map and search * Info about me * Info for survivors * Info about abuse * Info about churches * General info * My story * Survivors' bill of rights * Forgiveness and apologies * Perpetrator list * Email me